There’s a little-known secret among makeup enthusiasts: we don’t love touching up our makeup throughout the day. Once it’s on, we like to leave it alone and not fuss with it again. That’s where setting sprays come in – they create an invisible barrier that keeps makeup in place, no matter what the weather throws at us. With so many options out there, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one.
To help you make a decision, we’ve rounded up the top features to look for in a setting spray, and our top 7 picks for the best makeup setting sprays on the market. From budget-friendly options to premium choices, we’ve got you covered. Our list includes the best overall setting spray, the best premium option, and even the best setting spray for oily skin. We’ve also thrown in some honorable mentions for fixing sprays, which serve a similar purpose but have slightly different characteristics.
Ready… Get Set!
To fully appreciate the benefits of setting sprays, it’s essential to understand their purpose and how they work. Essentially, these products are designed to help your hairstyle last longer by controlling frizz, adding texture, and enhancing overall definition. By locking in place what you’ve achieved with styling products, a good setting spray can make all the difference between a decent ‘do and a truly exceptional one.
As we delve into reviews of various setting sprays, it’s crucial to have a solid grasp on what makes a great product, which is why we’re taking a moment to break down the key characteristics you should look for in a top-notch setting spray.
Setting Sprays vs. Fixing Sprays
The distinction between setting sprays and fixing sprays has become increasingly blurred, with many brands and bloggers using the terms interchangeably. However, these two products serve fundamentally different purposes. Setting sprays are designed to preserve your makeup look for hours on end, much like hair spray preserves a hairstyle. They typically contain a mixture of water, alcohol, film-forming polymers, and other additives that enhance their texture and skin feel.
While many consumers assume setting sprays will alter the finish of their makeup or control oil production, our research suggests that most setting sprays do not significantly impact either factor. In contrast, fixing sprays are designed to modify the existing makeup on your face rather than simply sitting atop it like a barrier. They often contain hydrating agents and plant extracts, which allow different layers of foundation and powder to blend seamlessly together.
This process not only extends wear time but also eliminates the telltale signs of cakey or powdery buildup, resulting in a more natural-looking finish. As we delve into the world of setting sprays throughout this article, we’ll also be reviewing the top 3 fixing sprays that can help you achieve a more refined makeup look.
Features to Look for in Setting Sprays
When evaluating makeup setting sprays, we prioritized several key features to ensure that only the most exceptional products made the cut. At the core of our criteria was effectiveness – a setting spray must be able to secure your makeup in place without compromising its integrity. This fundamental expectation applies to every product on our list. Another crucial consideration was the nozzle’s performance.
A well-designed nozzle ensures a smooth, even distribution of the spray, which is essential for achieving the desired finish. We’re not afraid to call out products with aggressive nozzles that can disrupt your makeup or leave it looking cakey. While the skin-feel aspect may seem like a secondary concern, we believe it’s an important trade-off between effectiveness and comfort.
The best setting sprays strike a balance between longevity and lightness, without compromising their ability to lock in your makeup. Our reviews will give you insight into which products excel in this regard. Fragrance is another factor that can make or break a setting spray. We appreciate when brands opt for pleasant scents or offer fragrance-free options for sensitive skin types.
Rest assured that our reviews cover the scent profiles of each product, so you know what to expect before making a purchase. Finally, we looked for setting sprays that incorporate skincare ingredients tailored to specific skin types. These thoughtful additions can enhance the overall benefits of the product and provide an added layer of protection. With these criteria in mind, let’s dive into our reviews of the top makeup setting sprays – regardless of budget or skin type.
Top 7 Best Makeup Setting Sprays 2024
Best Overall Setting Spray: Milani Make It Last 3-in-1 Setting Spray
This setting spray from Milani has won over the hearts of many beauty enthusiasts, including influencers across various social media platforms. What sets it apart is its exceptional performance at an affordable price point. The original version is a standout, made with a unique combination of PVP and Poloxamer 407 film formers. These polymers work in harmony with niacinamide, an antioxidant skincare ingredient that benefits all skin types.
Despite being a lesser-known brand, Milani has managed to create a product that surpasses expectations. The setting spray holds up incredibly well for 16 hours or more, resisting the wear and tear of makeup, oily skin, and water. Its performance is rivaled only by the Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray, although it can feel slightly heavier on the skin.
The packaging is another plus point – the bottle feels solid and durable, while the nozzle emits a fine mist that covers the face effortlessly. The scent is a lovely rose fragrance that masks any lingering notes of alcohol. While some might prefer an unscented setting spray, this one’s fragrance blends well with many perfumes. What really stands out, however, is the price point.
The bottle may be slightly smaller than others on the market, but it still delivers fantastic results at a price that’s accessible to most makeup lovers.
Best Premium Setting Spray: Urban Decay All Nighter Makeup Setting Spray
Urban Decay’s original setting spray has stood the test of time, boasting an intense formula that maintains makeup wearability for hours on end. This iconic product is a solid choice for all skin types, as it won’t alter the finish of your makeup. The secret to its success lies in its powerful blend of PVP and other film-formers, which work together to create an impenetrable barrier.
Like many setting sprays, Urban Decay claims its formula can last up to 16 hours, but with additional longevity-boosting steps, it’s not uncommon for the results to be even more impressive. However, some users may find the product feels slightly heavier on the skin compared to lighter alternatives like Milani. The benefits of this spray far outweigh the drawbacks for many, as it provides excellent wearability and a gentle, even application thanks to its simple yet effective sprayer.
While the price point is higher than some comparable products, Urban Decay’s setting spray offers exceptional value, especially considering its travel-sized option. For those seeking a more affordable alternative, L’Oreal’s Infallible Pro-Spray is another viable option, although the nozzle may not be as refined. The only notable drawback to this product is its fragrance, which can be noticeable to those with sensitive noses.
Best Budget Setting Spray: Rimmel Stay Matte Fix & Go
This Rimmel setting spray is an excellent choice for those on a tight budget, offering effective results without breaking the bank. The formula is particularly impressive, featuring hydrating ingredients that make it suitable for use both under and over makeup. While not cruelty-free or vegan, this product’s unique technology sets it apart from others in its class.
The polyurethane-14 and Amp-Acrylates Copolymer film formers provide a flexible and non-sticky texture, ensuring excellent skin-feel. If you’ve had limited success with setting sprays in the past, this one is still worth trying due to its distinct approach. Rimmel recommends using this spray as a primer, which can offer some hold for makeup applied on top.
The formula was reinforced with hydrating ingredients like sodium PCA, urea, and glycerin, allowing it to slightly meld makeup together like a fixing spray. Although the product doesn’t mattify the skin, it does an excellent job of preventing facial oils from disrupting makeup throughout the day, making it suitable for all skin types. For those seeking an actively mattifying face spray, the Maybelline Facestudio Lasting Fix Spray is the top recommendation.
The primary drawback of this setting spray is its aggressive nozzle, which releases a strong spray rather than a fine mist like some other products. However, with a few tips below, you can still effectively apply this setting spray.
Best Setting Spray for Oily Skin: Maybelline Facestudio Lasting Fix
This setting spray boasts an impressive matte finish, making it an excellent choice for those who want to keep their makeup in place throughout the day. The talc-infused formula is particularly effective at absorbing excess oils and reducing shine, even offering a strong touch-up capability. With its affordable price point and cruelty-free status, it’s no wonder why this product has gained popularity among beauty enthusiasts.
Notably, it offers an intense mattifying effect that rivals other high-end brands, thanks to its unique blend of Amp-Acrylates/Allyl Methacrylate Copolymer and PVP. While the formula may be a bit drying on dry or normal skin types, oily skin users will appreciate the product’s oil-absorbing properties. However, one area for improvement lies in the spray nozzle, which could benefit from a finer misting capability to prevent larger droplets of liquid from disrupting makeup.
Additionally, the strong scent of alcohol and film-formers may be off-putting for some users, but those with fragrance allergies will appreciate the product’s fragrance-free status. Overall, this setting spray is an excellent choice for oily skin types seeking a reliable and affordable option that delivers on its promise of a matte finish.
Best Affordable Heavy-Duty Spray: L’Oreal Paris Infallible Pro-Spray & Set
The L’Oreal setting spray offers a nearly identical formula to Urban Decay’s All Nighter Spray at a significantly lower price point. While the packaging may not be as sleek, it’s a great alternative for those who love the intense results of the original. In fact, both sprays contain the same main film-formers, resulting in similar performance and longevity. The only notable difference is the cost – L’Oreal’s spray is roughly half the price per ounce of Urban Decay’s equivalent.
If budget is a concern but you still want to experience the powerful effects of the original, this is an excellent choice. However, it’s not without its flaws. The packaging is plain and the nozzle can be a bit aggressive, distributing the fine mist unevenly. With careful application, these issues might not be a major problem, especially considering the lower cost.
Best SPF: Coola Organic Makeup Setting Sunscreen Spray
This setting spray not only sets your makeup but also provides a reliable layer of sun protection. While it may not be the strongest setting spray on the market, it still effectively prolongs the wear of your makeup. The PVP-based formula helps achieve a natural-looking finish that can also subtly mattify the skin for some users. Beyond its primary functions, the product contains a blend of organic plant extracts that promote hydration, soothe the skin, and offer antioxidant benefits.
As a result, it can refresh and rejuvenate the appearance of your makeup when reapplied.
For those familiar with cosmetic chemistry, combining setting effects and SPF is no easy feat. Given this challenge, we’re willing to overlook some minor drawbacks. The spray does have a potent scent, primarily due to the presence of alcohol and sun filters, which can be overwhelming at first. However, the fragrance eventually dissipates.
Additionally, the product leaves a subtle sticky texture on the skin that’s not visually apparent but may be unpleasant for some.
It’s also essential to note that shoppers with sensitive skin might find the chemical sunscreen filters used in this product incompatible with their skin type. If that’s the case, we recommend opting for a gentler setting spray like the NYX Makeup Setting Spray and relying on a mineral sunscreen powder for reapplications instead.
The product comes in a luxurious glass container, which while aesthetically pleasing, can make it less convenient to travel with. On the plus side, the organic ingredients used in this setting spray align with its cruelty-free and vegan status.
Best Setting Spray for Sensitive Skin: NYX Makeup Setting Spray Matte Finish
This fragrance-free setting spray from NYX offers a unique combination of benefits and drawbacks. On the plus side, it helps hold makeup in place without causing irritation, making it a great option for those with sensitive skin. The formula’s main polymer, VP/VA Copolymer, provides strong hold and water-resistance, although it does feel slightly heavier on the skin. When first applied, it adds a sheen that quickly dries down to a natural finish.
The product includes soothing skincare ingredients like sodium salicylate and niacinamide, which can help calm the skin. Additionally, its fragrance-free nature makes it suitable for those with fragrance allergies or sensitivities. However, some users may find the nozzle’s aggressive stream of liquid uncomfortable, requiring them to hold it at a distance from their face. The product also has a distinctive chemical smell that fades quickly after application.
Priced on the higher end of the drugstore range, it may not be the most budget-friendly option. Nevertheless, the 5 oz jumbo container offers great value for those who fall in love with this setting spray.
Top 3 Best Fixing Sprays 2024
Best Fixing Spray for Dry Skin: Catrice Prime & Fine Dewy Glow Spray
We adore this fixing spray for its exceptional ability to hydrate and add a radiant glow to dry skin. The secret lies in its unique formula, which combines water with powerful humectants that rehydrate powder and foundation, allowing them to meld together seamlessly. But what truly sets it apart is the addition of finely-milled mica minerals, which provide an intense yet diffused sheen.
This subtle shine not only enhances the natural glow of dry skin but also helps to create a smooth, even canvas for makeup. Unlike other fixing sprays that rely solely on moisture-binding ingredients for their hydrating effects, this one delivers a double whammy of hydration and reflection. As a result, the radiant look can last all day, making it an excellent choice for those with dry skin. Of course, as with any product, there are some caveats to consider.
For oily or combination skin types, the mica minerals may create an unflattering greasy sheen. However, for dry skin, this fixing spray is a game-changer. We recommend using it first, followed by a setting spray like the Milani Make It Last Setting Spray for added longevity. In our opinion, the pros far outweigh the cons.
The benefits of this fixing spray include its ability to meld layers of makeup together, provide a hydrating effect from its humectant blend, and add a dewy sheen that’s simply stunning on dry skin.
Best Premium Fixing Spray: MAC Prep + Prime Fix +
MAC Fix+ is a cult classic among beauty enthusiasts. This iconic post-makeup face spray predates many of its competitors, yet it remains an exceptional product that seamlessly blends makeup together with hydrating and soothing ingredients. Its versatility makes it suitable for all skin types at any time of day, whether you’re looking to refresh your look or enhance your natural glow.
With a blend of glycerin, chamomile, and green tea extracts, this spray not only reduces powderiness but also provides a subtle moisture boost. The nozzle has been perfected over the years, emitting a gentle mist that won’t disrupt your makeup. While it’s a bit pricey, the benefits far outweigh the cost. If you’re looking for a fragrance-free option, consider alternatives like Bella Jade Makeup Setting Spray.
In reality, MAC Fix+ is an outstanding post-makeup spray that will leave your skin feeling refreshed and looking radiant.
Best Natural Fixing Spray: Bella Jade Makeup Setting Spray
We’re big fans of this product, not because it’s a traditional setting spray that sets your makeup in place, but because it’s an excellent fixing spray that refreshes and hydrates your skin. The formula is packed with natural skin-soothing extracts, including green tea, white tea, rooibos tea, MSM, and sodium PCA. These ingredients work together to provide a calming and protective barrier for your skin, making it perfect for those who prefer natural products.
The nozzle produces a fine mist that spreads evenly across the skin, and the fragrance-free formula makes it suitable for even the most sensitive skin types.
This product has its downsides, of course – its name can be confusing, and it’s not as intensely hydrating as some other options on the market. However, if you’re looking for a lightweight fixing spray that will give your skin a gentle boost without feeling heavy or greasy, this is definitely worth considering.
Some highlights include:
* All-natural formula that’s perfect for those who prioritize natural ingredients
* Skin-soothing ingredients that work together to calm and protect the skin
* Fine mist disperses evenly across the skin without leaving any residue
* Fragrance-free formula makes it suitable for sensitive skin types.
Some drawbacks include:
* Confusing name that might lead you to expect a different product
* Not extremely hydrating, so it’s not ideal for dry or parched skin
The Complete Guide to Fixing & Setting Sprays
With so many fantastic options available, selecting the ideal spray can be a daunting task. To simplify your decision-making process, we’ve compiled this comprehensive guide, designed to walk you through the key considerations and factors to keep in mind when choosing the perfect spray for your unique needs.
Deciding Between a Setting Spray or Fixing Spray
When faced with the dilemma of choosing between a setting spray and a fixing spray, it’s essential to weigh the key differences between these two products. A setting spray is designed to help your hairstyle stay in place for an extended period, whereas a fixing spray is meant to prevent flyaways and add texture to your locks.
The main consideration is the purpose you intend to use the product for: if you’re looking to maintain a style that requires minimal maintenance, a setting spray might be the better choice; however, if you want to add some extra oomph to your hair and tame stray hairs, a fixing spray could be the way to go.
Choose a Setting Spray if…
For many of us, finding the right makeup products can be a challenge. Whether it’s dealing with smudged or faded makeup throughout the day, managing dry skin that requires a gentle setting powder, or needing a look that lasts all day without smearing off, we’ve all been there. Perhaps you’re gearing up for an extra-long day where you need your makeup to stay in place, or anticipating those humid and sweaty days when your makeup is more likely to migrate or smear.
Whatever the scenario, finding products that can keep up with our busy lives and varied environmental conditions can be a real struggle.
Choose a Fixing Spray if…
As you go about your day, you may find that your makeup looks dull and powdery. This can be frustrating, especially if you’re trying to achieve a flawless, long-lasting look. In addition to these cosmetic concerns, you may also experience dry or dehydrated skin, which can further exacerbate the issue. To address this, many of us seek out products that will help our makeup stay in place and keep our skin hydrated throughout the day.
One effective solution is to use a combination of setting spray and fixing spray when applying both foundation and powder. By doing so, you’ll be able to achieve a truly budge-proof beat that lasts all day long.
The Right Spray for Your Skin Type
When selecting a setting and fixing spray, consider your individual skin type: oily, dry, or sensitive. For oily skin, look for stronger setting sprays like Urban Decay’s All Nighter Setting Spray, which can help keep makeup intact despite oil production. Maybelline’s Facestudio Lasting Fix Spray is another great option that helps tame shine.
On the other hand, dry skin types will benefit from lighter setting sprays like Milani’s Make It Last Setting Spray, which can be used as a replacement for powder to avoid emphasizing dryness. For added moisture and glow, consider fixing sprays rich in hydrating ingredients such as Catrice’s Dewy Glow Spray or MAC’s Prep + Prime Fix+. Sensitive skin types should opt for fragrance-free setting sprays like NYX’s Makeup Setting Spray or NYX’s option specifically designed for oily skin.
When applying these products, remember to use them at the very end of your makeup routine and avoid direct contact with the skin.
Is Setting Spray Bad for Your Skin?
While setting sprays may not be the best for your skin, they’re not entirely detrimental either. The film-forming ingredients that can raise concerns are actually safe when assessed by reputable organizations like the Environmental Working Group. They rate PVP and VP/VA copolymer as posing no risk to consumers. Other potential issues arise from the presence of alcohol, which can dry out the skin, and fragrances, which may cause irritation.
However, in a setting spray, these ingredients are typically layered beneath moisturizers, primers, and makeup, limiting their contact with the skin and minimizing any negative effects.
Can You Use Hairspray as Setting Spray?
While some may suggest using hairspray as a makeup hack, it’s crucial to exercise caution. A significant difference between hairspray and makeup setting spray is the presence of propellants in aerosols. This design feature increases the risk of eye contact and inhalation, making it a less desirable choice for personal use.
According to the National Capital Poison Center, even minor exposure to hairspray can cause irritation to the eyes and respiratory pathways, potentially leading to long-term adverse effects if inhaled regularly. Furthermore, hairsprays are designed for the hair, not skin, and typically contain stronger fragrances, making them more likely to cause skin irritation.
How Do You Use Makeup Setting Spray?
To get the most out of your makeup setting spray, it’s essential to know when and how to use it correctly. The key is to apply it at the right moment in your beauty routine. As a general rule, it’s best to wait until you’ve almost finished applying your makeup, with the exception being waterproof mascara – for that, spray first and make it your last step.
When spraying your setting spray, start by holding the bottle about 8-10 inches away from your face, slightly above eye level.
This will ensure an even distribution of the mist. Close your eyes and mouth tightly as you gently press down on the nozzle to release a fine mist onto your skin.
As you move your face side to side, allow the spray to cover every area evenly. To get to those hard-to-reach areas, like the lower part of your face, simply tilt the bottle slightly while keeping it at a comfortable distance.
Once you’ve covered your entire face with the setting spray, wait for a few minutes before touching your makeup again. This allows the product to fully dry and set in place. If your setting spray has a more powerful nozzle, consider spraying it into the air first, then allowing the mist to fall onto your skin.
To speed up the drying process, you can use a fan or experiment with different application techniques.
For instance, you can apply multiple layers of setting spray throughout your makeup routine – try layering it over your primer, after foundation, and after setting powder to achieve the desired effect. Remember, the key is to find what works best for you and your unique skin type.
What Else Can You Do to Get Your Makeup to Last?
To ensure your makeup stays put all-day and all-night, start by prepping your skin with a face primer that suits your skin type. This simple step prevents foundation from settling into pores or fine lines, while also extending its longevity. You can even get creative and use your setting spray as a primer – some users swear by the sticky layer it creates, which grips foundation beautifully. When applying cream products like foundation and concealer, remember: less is more.
Thin layers mean less movement and smudging throughout the day. For an added boost, consider skipping powder altogether and relying on setting sprays for the best results. Of course, the condition of your skin plays a crucial role in makeup longevity too. By keeping your skin well-hydrated through a consistent skincare routine, you’ll be rewarded with longer-lasting makeup that looks great all day long.
Finishing Touches
Achieving a flawless finish and maintaining it throughout the day can be a daunting task, especially when it comes to setting sprays and fixing sprays. However, grasping the fundamental principles of how they operate is crucial for achieving that polished look. By understanding their functions, you’ll be able to tackle even the most challenging situations with poise and confidence.
