When it comes to lip color, there’s one type of stain that’s uniquely beneficial: the non-smudging, all-day-wearing lip stain. Unlike lipstick, which can smudge and smear throughout the day, lip stains are designed to stay in place, providing a subtle, long-lasting color. But what makes them so special? And how do they differ from other types of lip products? Let’s dive into the world of lip stains and explore their unique characteristics, benefits, and top-rated options.
The Low-Down on Lip Stains
While we’re enthusiastic about lip stains, we acknowledge that the term can be somewhat ambiguous. To provide clarity, this section will define what ‘lip stain’ means in the context of cosmetics, and highlight the key considerations to keep in mind when selecting a product. By understanding these nuances, you’ll be better equipped to find a lip stain that suits your preferences.
What Does a Lip Stain Do?
While lip stains offer a vibrant hue for the lips with a unique formula designed to resist fading and smudging, the modern beauty industry’s inconsistency leads to variations in formulation. Rather than a single standard formula, there exist three distinct types of lip stains that set them apart from one another.
Types of Lip Stains
The lip stain market offers a diverse range of products, categorized into three primary types: liquid lipsticks, liquid tints, and balm tints. Liquid lipsticks are characterized by their high pigmentation levels and matte finishes, often favored for their bold appearance. In contrast, liquid tints are designed to provide a natural-looking flush, which has gained immense popularity in Korea.
Balm tints, on the other hand, offer a more subtle approach with lower pigmentation levels, while also moisturizing both lips and cheeks. Later in this piece, we’ll delve deeper into each category, providing insight to aid in your decision-making process as you determine which type is best suited for you.
Finish, Pigmentation & Color
When considering the perfect flooring option, it’s crucial to consider various factors such as finish, pigmentation, and color. While these elements play a significant role in our reviews, ultimately the right choice for you depends on your personal taste and aesthetic preferences. If you’re still undecided, this guide aims to provide valuable insights to help you make an informed decision that aligns with your unique style.
Longevity
Most lip stains are designed to provide long-lasting wear, with some exceptions. To give you a better idea of what to expect, we’ll provide information on the duration each lip stain stays on and its resistance to food and drinks.
Non-Transferring
When it comes to applying lip color, leaving behind unsightly stains is the last thing you want to worry about. This is why most lip stain products we recommend are formulated to be non-transferring. In other words, they’re designed to only leave a mark on your lips themselves, rather than transferring onto fabrics or skin.
Easy to Use
When evaluating each lip stain in our reviews, we take a holistic approach by describing the actual experience of using them. This includes assessing the ease and speed of application, which can be crucial considerations for both seasoned makeup enthusiasts and those new to the world of cosmetics or with limited time to devote to their daily routine.
Pleasant Lip Feel
While longevity and pigmentation are essential qualities in a lip stain, they often require compromise on comfort. A pleasant surprise is when a lip stain feels lightweight and moisturizing on the lips. As we test each product throughout the day, we’ll provide details on how it performs in this regard. Having set the stage for our review, let’s now dive into the top lip stains of 2024, a selection that promises to delight.
Top 10 Best Lip Stains 2024
Best Overall Lip Stain: Covergirl Outlast All-Day Lip Color
The Outlast Lip Color is a standout product that boasts high-pigmentation and intense longevity. This liquid lipstick with built-in topcoat balm delivers a flawless, opaque finish that lasts for over 12 hours, even after eating or drinking. The stain itself comes in a range of 34 shades, all of which dry down to a matte texture, although some may contain a subtle shimmer for added flair. What sets this product apart is its unique two-in-one design.
Not only can you wear the stain on its own for a sleek, matte look, but you can also use the balm as a topcoat and sealant to add a creamy sheen. This versatility makes it easy to customize your look, whether you prefer a bold, matte lip or a more subtle, glossy finish. While the Outlast Lip Color is a great option for those seeking long-lasting, high-pigmentation lip color, it’s not without its limitations.
The product can be unforgiving of texture and may settle into creases in the lips, feathering at the lip line, especially over mature skin. To get the best results, make sure to keep your lips thoroughly moisturized and consider using a lip primer if you’re prone to feathering. Overall, this cruelty-free, two-in-one lip stain is a great choice for those seeking a reliable, high-quality lip color that delivers on its promises.
Best Budget Lip Stain: Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick
Maybelline’s liquid lipstick formula is a game-changer for those seeking a long-lasting, high-pigmentation product. With its satin finish and 16-hour wear, it’s perfect for busy days or intense activities. The formula offers impressive smudge-proofing and transfer-resistance, even when confronted with greasy food. In fact, the darker shades can leave a multi-day stain, making it a great option for those who want their lip color to last.
With 45 shades available, there’s something for every style and preference. While it may not have a true matte finish as advertised, its satin sheen is still quite pretty. However, if a true matte-finish is desired, other options like the Cream Lip Stain from Sephora may be a better choice. Upon application, the formula dries quickly but can feel a little sticky on the lips. Despite this, the color remained in place without transferring.
Overall, Maybelline’s liquid lipstick offers many pros, including incredible longevity, smudge-proofing, intense pigmentation, and an excellent color range. However, it does have some cons, such as not being matte and difficulty removing the product.
Best Premium Lip Stain: Benefit Cosmetics Benetint Lip & Cheek Stain
When it comes to lip stains, few products have managed to stand the test of time like Benetint. The original formula has remained a favorite among many for decades, and it’s easy to see why. Benetint is a liquid tint that requires only a tiny amount to give lips a natural-looking flush that doesn’t fade or transfer too easily. The low pigmentation means you can build up the color gradually to achieve the desired level of intensity.
While some might view lip stains as a modern innovation, Benetint has actually been around since 1976, when it was first developed. Over the years, the formula has undergone some changes, but its core properties remain the same: a thin, pigmented liquid that sinks into the lips. The original shade gives lips a rosy tint, although additional soft shades have been released in recent years.
Benetint is best suited for those seeking a natural look and can also be used on the cheeks to add a touch of color. Applying the product requires some finesse: apply a small swipe over the lips and then blend it in by rubbing your lips together or using your finger. Be careful not to use too much at once, as this can lead to uneven settling. It’s also essential to start with well-moisturized lips to ensure a smooth application.
While Benetint can transfer slightly when first applied, it becomes transfer-proof once it sets and sinks into the lips. If you stick to a thin layer, the liquid will absorb quickly, leaving you with a natural finish. You can add more layers for a more saturated color, which will also give your lips a lustrous appearance for a few hours. The formula’s decent longevity means it can hold up for around 6-7 hours, although eating greasy food may cause the color to fade.
A lip balm applied on top will help retain the color while providing moisture to dry lips. If you’re looking for an affordable alternative with a similar formulation, consider the Water Tints from Etude House. Just be aware that they are slightly more pigmented than Benetint.
Best Hybrid Lip Stain: Peripera Ink Airy Velvet Lip Tint
This unique Korean lip stain is a game-changer, blending the best of both worlds – the smooth, creamy texture of a liquid lipstick and the subtle color payoff of a liquid tint. The ‘Airy Velvet’ formula has a velvety matte finish that’s perfect for achieving those on-trend K-beauty looks. The packaging is also adorable, featuring a dropper-like top with a doe-foot applicator that prevents excess product from getting on your lips.
While it may not be as intensely pigmented as some liquid lipsticks, the medium-level color payoff allows for buildable coverage and a natural-looking finish. Applying lightly is key to achieving the best results – pack on too much color and you risk smudging or cracking, but with a light hand, the formula behaves like a stain, leaving behind a beautiful, subtle wash of color.
The shade range may be limited, but the universally-flattering hues make it easy to find a color that suits your natural coloring. Just note that Peripera’s color representations can be off-base, so be sure to check out swatch videos before making a final decision. In terms of pros, this lip stain excels at being smooth and comfortable to wear, perfect for matte K-beauty looks, easy to apply, and surprisingly forgiving on dry lips.
Cons include the limited shade range and the fact that it’s not ideal for heavier applications – but overall, this innovative formula is a must-try for anyone looking to add some Korean beauty flair to their daily routine.
Best Mid-End Lip Stain: SEPHORA COLLECTION Cream Lip Stain
Sephora’s liquid lipstick-style stains have won our hearts with their impressive longevity, rich pigmentation, and soft matte finish. With an astonishing 90+ shades to choose from, including rare colors like teal, black, and forest green, you’re bound to find a perfect match. The formula is traditional for liquid lipsticks, providing one-swipe coverage that lasts for hours without transferring. The removal process is surprisingly easy with most makeup removers.
Despite being a bit drying, the lip stains are a great option for those who have some experience with makeup or are willing to practice. Keep in mind that you should exfoliate and moisturize your lips before using them. If you’re looking for a similar product without the matte finish, we recommend Maybelline’s SuperStay Liquid Lipstick instead. The pros of these lip stains include fantastic longevity, saturated color coverage, an incredible shade range, and affordability by Sephora standards.
However, they can be a bit challenging for beginners, and some users might find them drying.
Best High-Shine Lip Stain: theBalm theBalmJour Lip Stain
We’re thrilled to introduce this innovative lip stain from theBalm, a brand that’s committed to cruelty-free and vegan practices. The formula is unlike anything we’ve seen before – it starts off as a glossy pigmented stain, but over time, it fades into a soft, long-lasting natural color. The result is a comfortable, moisturizing finish that’s perfect for those who want a subtle look that lasts. At 0.22 Fl. Oz., the product is compact and easy to carry around.
With an impressive 8-color range, you’re sure to find a shade that suits your style. While it may not be transfer-proof during its glossy phase, once it mattifies, it’s surprisingly durable. We appreciate theBalm’s effort to push the boundaries of traditional lip stains and look forward to seeing them expand their color range in the future.
Best Korean Lip Stain: Etude House Dear Darling Water Tint
The Water Tint Liquid Lip Stains have gained immense popularity globally, especially in South Korea. These liquid lip stains offer a natural-looking pout with long-lasting wear that can be built up for more dramatic looks. While they don’t provide intense moisture, they won’t dry out the lips either. The texture is thin and lightweight, allowing for effortless application and blending. In practice, they share similarities with Benefit’s Benetint Stain, but with a few key differences.
Firstly, the Water Tint colors are more pigmented, making it easier to build up the color and achieve vivid results. This feature works particularly well for creating a gradient lip effect common in K-beauty trends. To get the most out of these liquid lip stains, use a good lip liner to prevent feathering. However, be aware that the high pigmentation can accentuate dryness on the lips.
The shade range consists of three colors: Cherry, a soft neutral red; Orange, a warm orange-red; and Strawberry, a cool purple-pink. As with any makeup product, the final result will depend on one’s natural lip color. Notably, these liquid lip stains are significantly more affordable than their premium counterparts, making them an attractive option for anyone who enjoys this type of product.
While we think they’re suitable for most users, those with traditionally Western makeup styles may not appreciate their unique features.
Best Moisturizing Lip Stain: jane iredale Just Kissed Lip and Cheek Stain
This Jane Iredale cheek and lip stain is a game-changer for those who hate drying lip products. Its unique blend of avocado, olive, and jojoba oils creates a creamy texture that melts onto the lips, leaving them feeling soft and moisturized. The formula’s low pigmentation makes it perfect for adding a gentle wash of color without overpowering the natural tone of the lips. The three shades available – warm peach, cool pink, and dynamic red – are easy to apply and blend into the skin.
You can use it as you would any lip balm or bullet lipstick, making it beginner-friendly. The best part? Because the pigmentation is so low, it’s hard to make mistakes, so it’s a great choice for those who don’t want to fuss too much with their makeup. In terms of longevity, this stain isn’t meant to last all day. It will start to fade gently after three to four hours of wear, and may leave a bit of a stain behind. However, the lips look fine once it fades, and reapplication is a breeze.
While this product may be pricier than some others on the market, its natural formula and moisturizing properties make it well worth the investment. For those looking for a similar product at a lower price point, the Pacifica Color Quench Lip Tints are a great alternative – although they do have a slightly dated shimmer.
Best Drugstore Lip Stain: L’Oreal Paris Rouge Signature Matte Lip Stain
L’Oréal’s liquid lipstain line is a standout for its unique blend of vibrant color and comfortable wear. The matte finish provides long-lasting results, and the formula feels surprisingly cooling and soothing on the lips. With 35 colors to choose from, there’s something for everyone in this range. One of the most notable features of these lipstains is their texture – it’s almost water-like when applied, making them a joy to wear.
The drawback is that they take a little longer to dry down, but applying the stain and then blotting it can help speed up the process while also reducing intensity. Pigmentation is intense, so you can build up layers without worrying about uneven color or cakiness. And once applied, these lipstains stay comfortable throughout the day, never becoming dry or sticky.
The applicator is another plus – a pointed teardrop shape makes lining the lips a breeze, and the fat bottom ensures quick coverage of the rest of the lip. While these lipstains may not be perfect – they don’t last as long as some other options on the market, and there’s some transfer involved – their comfort and wearability make them a great choice for those who prioritize feeling good on their lips.
If you’re looking for a vibrant, matte finish that won’t dry out your lips, these are definitely worth considering.
Best Vegan Lip Stain: Pacifica Beauty Color Quench Lip Tint
Pacifica’s vegan lip balms and stains offer a unique blend of moisture and color. These sheer, nourishing formulas are made with coconut oil, soy wax, and botanical ingredients, providing long-lasting hydration for dry lips. While they lack intense pigmentation, the subtle tint gives lips a soft wash of color. The standout feature is their ability to be used as cheek stains, adding a highlight effect. When layered over a liquid tint, they can create a stunning, multi-dimensional look.
While they may not be long-lasting, their ease of use and moisturizing properties make them an excellent choice for everyday wear. As a bonus, the frosty finish provides a subtle sheen that adds depth to the overall appearance.
The Total Guide to Lip Stains
Not convinced yet? No worries! To further demystify the art of achieving the ideal pout, we’ve included additional insights and expert advice to guide you towards your goal. So, let’s dive in and explore the secrets to a picture-perfect pucker.
Lip Stain Types in Detail
In addition to their varying formulas, lip stains also differ in terms of benefits and characteristics. Let’s delve into the specifics. Liquid lipsticks are a type of stain that offers long-lasting color with a creamy texture that dries down to an immovable layer. While they provide excellent longevity, they can be heavy and uncomfortable to wear, especially if they have a matte finish.
However, they remain the most popular option, which is why our top pick from Covergirl’s Outlast Lip Color makes the cut. On the other end of the spectrum are liquid tints, which create a subtle, natural-looking stain that enhances the lips’ natural color rather than covering them. This effect can be likened to having a ‘bitten’ or ‘flushed’ appearance. Liquid tints have gained immense popularity in Korea, where they’re often used as cheek stains.
While they may take some practice to apply, they offer great longevity and zero transfer. Balm tints, by contrast, are the most moisturizing of the bunch. They combine the nourishing properties of a lip balm with a light staining effect. These products don’t offer the same level of pigmentation or longevity as their liquid counterparts but provide unparalleled comfort and ease of application. They work well on the cheeks too.
Ultimately, these three types of lip stains cater to different needs and preferences. From casual, low-maintenance options like balm tints to bold, long-lasting statements with liquid lipsticks, there’s a stain out there for everyone. Even pairing products from different categories can lead to unique looks that suit individual styles.
Tips for Using Lip Stains
For a flawless finish with any lip stain, remember these simple tips. To keep your lips hydrated and flake-free, apply a lip balm regularly and exfoliate them gently with a lip scrub a few times a week. When applying your lip stain, opt for thin layers to ensure it lasts throughout the day. If you want to tone down a glossy or creamy finish, use a light dusting of translucent powder to absorb excess shine.
And finally, don’t be afraid to get creative and use your balm or liquid lip stains as blushes on your cheeks – the natural-looking flush will perfectly complement your bold lip color.
How to Remove a Persistent Lip Stain
When dealing with persistent lip stains, it’s common to find that they don’t budge easily. However, with the right techniques and products, you can effectively remove them without causing any irritation or damage to your lips. One effective approach is to use oil-based cleansers or pure oils, as these tend to break down makeup more efficiently. If you’re removing all of your makeup, start by massaging the oil cleanser onto your entire face, before focusing on the lips at the end.
For the lip stain specifically, gently wipe it away with your finger, taking care not to spread it across your face. Once you’ve removed the lip stain, follow up by rinsing off any remaining makeup and cleanser residue with a soft cloth or facial rinse. Alternatively, if you’re only removing lipstick while keeping the rest of your makeup intact, soak a cotton pad with your preferred remover and gently wipe over the lips from the outside in to avoid smudging other areas.
Kiss Touch-ups Goodbye
Say goodbye to the frustrations of traditional lipsticks – smudging, fading, and reapplications galore. Instead, discover the reliability and versatility of lip stains that cater to your unique preferences, whether you’re a fan of bold, intense colors or soft, subtle shades. Our curated list features a range of options that will meet your needs and provide long-lasting wear.
