Throughout history, perfectly shaped eyebrows have been a beauty staple. While some are naturally blessed with full and well-proportioned brows, others may struggle to achieve the desired look without assistance. Fear not, as there are various eyebrow fillers available to help you master the latest trends. These products come in a range of formulas and colors, each designed to enhance your natural brow shape and thickness.
They can also be used to expertly fill in gaps and leave you with flawless, natural-looking results. With so many options on the market, selecting the perfect eyebrow filler can be overwhelming. To ease this process, we’ve compiled a list of the top 10 best eyebrow fillers currently available. Read on to learn more about each product.
What You Should Know About Eyebrow Fillers
In order to appreciate the unique characteristics of eyebrow fillers, it’s essential to understand what sets them apart. When evaluating these products, several key factors come into play, including their ingredients, texture, and overall effectiveness in achieving desired results.
Why Use an Eyebrow Filler?
Whether you’re seeking to enhance the definition and prominence of your existing eyebrows, alter their shape or size, or achieve a fuller, more luscious appearance, eyebrow fillers can be an effective solution. These treatments can help to create a more natural-looking frame for your eyes by filling in sparse areas, refining shapes, or even adding volume to thin or fine brows.
Formula
When it comes to eyebrow fillers, there are various formulations available, each catering to different needs and preferences. Understanding these differences can help you choose the right product for your brows. Gel-based formulas, such as Benefit’s Gimme Brow Volumizing Fiber Gel, offer a thicker texture that adds color and tames unruly brow hairs, resulting in a bolder look. Some gel products may also contain added fibers to enhance volumization.
Pencil-based fillers are the most accessible and affordable option, allowing for easy shaping or adding individual hairs. However, they might not be ideal for achieving a very full or thick brow appearance. Pomades, like Milani Stay Put Brow Color, provide a creamy texture and can be applied with an angled brush, offering greater control over brow style and shape. This type of filler is great for creating rich colors and defined shapes.
Powder-based fillers are perfect for filling small gaps in hair or enhancing overall brow color, resulting in a softer, more natural look. Powder formulas can also be combined with brow wax to improve hold and longevity. If you’re on a budget, consider products that offer both powder and wax components, such as our best value pick.
Color
When selecting an eyebrow filler color, it’s essential to choose one that harmoniously complements your natural hair color. Aim for a shade that is either identical or slightly darker than your locks. Avoid selecting a color that is too dark or too light, as this can create an unnatural contrast with the rest of your hair. For further guidance on finding the perfect eyebrow filler hue, refer to our comprehensive guide below.
Longevity
When it comes to choosing an eyebrow makeup product, one crucial consideration is how long it will stay put. Depending on your needs, you may want a formula that can withstand the test of time. Waterproof options, pomades, and gels are great choices for those seeking all-day hold, while pencils and powders tend to have a shorter lifespan.
If you’re looking for an eyebrow filler that will remain in place for hours, consider skipping ahead to our recommendation for Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio Brow Pomade. With this information under your belt, let’s dive into the top 10 eyebrow fillers on the market!
Top 10 Best Eyebrow Fillers 2024
Best Overall Eyebrow Filler: Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil
The Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil is a user-friendly option for those new to eyebrow filling. Its angled teardrop-shaped tip allows for effortless creation of natural-looking strokes, while the attached spoolie enables easy blending of any excess color. With four available colors that remain true to their shade, this pencil provides buildable coverage, making it suitable for both everyday wear and bolder looks. Notably, it excels at filling in thin brows and gentle shaping.
However, its performance is somewhat marred by the fact that once applied, the color doesn’t last long, prone to smudging and requiring frequent touch-ups. If you’re seeking a more enduring solution, consider pairing this pencil with another product designed to set the color in place.
Best Premium Eyebrow Filler: Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Definer
When it comes to the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Definer, one of its most significant advantages is its impressive range of colors and gentle ingredients. This premium eyebrow filler caters to individuals with sensitive skin, boasting a formula that minimizes the risk of irritation or adverse reactions. With 10 natural-looking shades to choose from, users can effortlessly find their perfect match. The Brow Definer’s angled tip, while slightly thicker than usual, excels at creating fuller brows.
However, it’s worth noting that the pencil’s formula is slightly waxier and more challenging to apply compared to other products on the market. For those seeking a smoother application experience, we recommend exploring alternative options like the Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil. Despite its minor drawbacks, this eyebrow filler excels in several areas.
Its color variety is particularly noteworthy, making it an attractive choice for those looking to achieve a natural-looking brow.
Best Budget Eyebrow Filler: Rimmel Brow This Way Sculpting Kit
Rimmel’s Brow This Way Sculpting Kit is a versatile and affordable option for those looking to fill in or sculpt their eyebrows. We’re fond of this product because it allows for a range of effects, from subtle enhancements to bold new shapes. The kit includes both a tinted wax and colored powder, which can be used separately or together to achieve the desired look. The compact size makes it easy to carry on-the-go.
While the color palette is somewhat limited with only three options available, each one offers a rich, saturated hue that’s perfect for those with darker hair. If you have lighter locks, however, you may find the colors run slightly dark, making it less suitable for your needs. Overall, this product is great value for its price point and provides a good balance of performance and portability.
Best Waterproof Eyebrow Filler: L’Oreal Brow Stylist Definer Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil
L’Oreal’s Brow Stylist pencil stands out for its impressive range of benefits. This waterproof, smudge-proof, and ophthalmologist-tested formula ensures a safe and gentle experience on all skin types. With 10 vibrant colors to choose from, you can create a customized brow look that suits your style. The product’s durability is also noteworthy, resisting the effects of sweat, rain, or accidental wiping without compromising its color or texture.
While some users may experience minor flaking when the color dries, this can be easily prevented by using the included spoolie to evenly distribute the pigment and avoid clumping. However, it’s worth noting that the pencil does have a relatively short lifespan compared to other brow products on the market.
Most Precise Eyebrow Filler: NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil
The NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil is a favorite among those who appreciate precise eyebrow filling. Its lightweight formula makes it an excellent choice for creating a natural-looking brow. The pencil’s small tip allows for meticulous control over the shape and darkness of your brows, allowing you to expertly craft a subtle look that seamlessly blends with your features.
The retractable design eliminates the need for sharpening, while the smooth application and non-sticky formula ensure a comfortable wear. However, the colored portion of the pencil has a tendency to break off easily, requiring gentle strokes when applying to prevent damage. Furthermore, it can be prone to crumbling if transported, making it less than ideal for on-the-go touch-ups.
Despite this limitation, the product’s pros far outweigh its cons, particularly for those who value precision and a natural finish.
Best Eyebrow Filler Pomade: Milani Stay Put Brow Color
The Milani Stay Put Brow Color pomade is a standout product in the world of eyebrow care. Its unique blend of creamy richness and versatility makes it an excellent choice for anyone looking to create a wide range of brow shapes and styles. The formula, which is both vegan and cruelty-free, boasts a smooth application that leaves a luxurious feel on the skin. This buildable coverage allows users to effortlessly craft thicker, more dramatic brows or precision-tailored looks with ease.
Whether you’re a fan of bold or subtle eyebrow statements, this pomade makes it simple to achieve your desired look. While it does require a bit of skill to master the application technique and get the hang of using the included brush, the payoff is well worth the initial learning curve. With proper practice, users can confidently create stunning brows that are both natural-looking and on-point.
Best Eyebrow Filler Kit: NYX Professional Makeup Eyebrow Cake Powder
This eyebrow filler kit boasts an impressive combination of two powders and one wax, allowing users to craft a flawless 3D brow look. The powder formulas offer a range of versatility, with one shade slightly darker than the other, enabling users to mix and match hues to perfectly complement their natural brow color. This subtle blend can help create a realistic appearance, giving the illusion of fuller brows without appearing artificial or clumpy.
For those seeking a more defined shape, particularly arched brows that require additional definition, this kit is an excellent choice. However, daily eyebrow filler users may find this product’s petite-sized powders and wax insufficient for their needs, as it may not provide long-lasting results. In contrast, Rimmel’s Brow This Way Sculpting Kit offers a more generous supply of product.
Most Long-Lasting Eyebrow Filler: Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio Brow Pomade
This pomade stands out for its remarkable durability, with the ability to last for at least 24 hours and up to 3 days under normal conditions. The highly pigmented formula allows for a dramatic eyebrow look, requiring minimal effort for maintenance. The included spoolie is surprisingly soft and effective in blending the color, making it suitable for both natural and bold brow styles. One area where the product falls short is its brush, which tends to break easily.
Users may need to use an alternative brush for application. Additionally, the pomade has a tendency to dry quickly, necessitating swift blending before clumps form on the brow. Nevertheless, its long-lasting properties, vibrant color, and efficient spoolie make it an attractive option for those seeking a low-maintenance eyebrow solution.
Best Eyebrow Filler Gel: NYX Professional Makeup Eyebrow Gel
This gel formula boasts a hardy design that can withstand any day’s demands, keeping your brows perfectly in shape. Its robust texture makes it ideal for thinning brows or fine hair, helping to bulk them up and create a dramatic look with bold definition. It excels at crafting short, thick brow shapes or enhancing arches. The opaque, matte finish provides an intense look that stays vibrant once applied.
Moreover, the formula’s durability ensures it remains in place even amidst sweaty workouts or humid conditions. A great choice for active individuals who require a product that can keep up with their lifestyle. While no eyebrow brush is included, you may need to purchase one separately for proper application. Additionally, the consistency is slightly thicker than some users prefer, making it more challenging to spread and blend.
For those seeking an easier, smoother application, options like Milani Stay Put Brow Color might be a better fit.
Best Volumizing Eyebrow Filler: Benefit Gimme Brow Volumizing Fiber Gel
This eyebrow filler boasts a unique formula that utilizes microfibers to create the illusion of thicker, fuller brows. The gel-based product is available in six different shades, catering to various preferences and hair types. When applied, the fibers bind to both skin and eyebrow hairs, producing a natural-looking enhancement of volume and thickness.
This attribute makes it an excellent choice for those seeking a shorter, more full-bodied brow appearance, particularly those with thin or sparse eyebrows who struggle to achieve the desired look. While the product’s coverage is buildable, allowing for customization of the level of fullness, it does come at a slightly higher price point. Additionally, the handle may be somewhat short, necessitating the use of an additional spoolie to blend out the application and prevent clumping.
Despite these minor drawbacks, the pros of this product far outweigh the cons, making it a valuable addition to any brow-care routine.
Your Full Guide to Eyebrow Fillers
For those seeking a comprehensive understanding of eyebrow fillers, look no further. Our extensive guide offers unparalleled insight into what you need to know to get the best results from your chosen product.
The Benefits of Using Eyebrow Fillers
Beyond mere brow grooming, eyebrow fillers offer a multitude of advantages. They can serve as a key component in achieving a polished, full-faced makeup look or provide a convenient means to exude effortless chic on days when you opt for a natural vibe. Furthermore, they enable you to effortlessly keep pace with the latest eyebrow trends, allowing you to effortlessly update your brow shape and style at will.
Moreover, these fillers offer a safer alternative to traditional methods like plucking and waxing, which can be damaging and time-consuming.
How to Fill in Your Eyebrows
To fill in your eyebrows, start by examining them in the mirror and noting any areas where the hair is thin. Identify the end of each eyebrow (the tail) as this will guide your application. For a pencil-based approach, begin in the middle of your eyebrow and use gentle strokes to fill in the hair, employing an upwards flicking motion for optimal results. Gradually work your way down towards the tail, taking care not to apply too much color in this area.
The front section can be filled in with more color to create a slightly darker appearance. When switching to powder, pomade, or gel products, ensure you have the right tools – a small-angled brush is often sufficient for making thin, precise strokes and achieving a natural-looking brow. Remember that it’s okay if your initial application isn’t perfect; start with light strokes and subtle color before building up to achieve the desired look.
If needed, refer to our section on eyebrow shapes and styles for guidance in selecting the best shape for your face.
Choosing Eyebrow Filler Color
When selecting an eyebrow filler color, several factors come into play. One crucial consideration is your natural hair color. For a subtle, soft appearance, opt for a shade closely matching your natural locks. If you prefer a bolder look, choose a color one or one and a half shades darker. Another key factor is the undertone of your skin – an eyebrow filler with harmonious undertones will blend seamlessly with your complexion.
To achieve a flawless, 3D-effect brow, don’t be afraid to experiment with different colors. Mixing and matching shades that complement your hair can create a dynamic, natural-looking appearance. This might involve combining products like pencils, gels, or pomades, or using a product like NYX Professional Makeup Eyebrow Cake Powder, which offers multiple shades to customize your look.
Eyebrow Shapes and Style
When it comes to crafting the perfect eyebrow shape, one of the most daunting tasks is deciding which style to go for, especially if you’re new to shaping your brows. To help you make an informed decision, we’ve compiled a comprehensive list of the most popular eyebrow shapes, including their characteristics and recommended products. The Hard Angled look features a noticeable arch in the middle of the brow, giving it a dramatic and defined appearance.
For this style, a pencil like Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil is a great choice. On the other end of the spectrum, the Soft Rounded shape has no visible arch and can soften sharp facial features, making it an ideal option for those with more angular faces. A product like Benefit’s Gimme Brow can help achieve this look by adding volume to your brows. The S-Shaped brow is characterized by a slight dip in the middle of the brow, which then arches before reaching the tail.
This style requires minimal maintenance and can be achieved using a pencil or pomade. For those with thicker brows, the Straight shape may be the way to go. This style doesn’t feature any visible curve or arch and can be enhanced with volumizing products like Benefit’s Gimme Brow. Tapered brows are thicker at the front and middle and thinner near the tail, requiring more shaping and maintenance than other styles.
A product like Milani Stay Put Brow Color can help you achieve this look by adding color to your brows. The Long Tail shape features a tail that extends past the corner of the eye, which requires a pencil or pomade to draw on. This style is ideal for those who want to add some drama to their brow game. Thick brows are often shorter and don’t feature a long tail, making them an easy-to-maintain option.
A product like Milani Stay Put Brow Color can help you achieve this look by adding color to your brows. The Middle Arched shape features a noticeable arch right in the middle of the brow, which requires some maintenance via plucking or threading to achieve. Finally, the End Arched shape is a classic style that features an arch close to the tail of the brow. This style flatters almost every face shape and can be achieved using a pencil or pomade.
Remember, when it comes to achieving naturally filled-in brows, it’s essential to select a shape that’s close to your natural brow shape. This will help you avoid excessive manipulation via plucking, waxing, or threading.
Do Eyebrow Fillers Have Side Effects?
While eyebrow fillers are generally considered a low-risk beauty product, it’s essential to acknowledge that individual reactions can still occur. In most cases, they won’t cause brow hair thinning or weakness like plucking or waxing methods might. Nevertheless, if you have sensitive skin, you may experience itchiness or an allergic reaction to the ingredients used in certain eyebrow fillers. If this happens, discontinue use and consult a healthcare professional if the reaction persists.
To ensure your safety, always thoroughly read product labels and be aware of any potential allergens.
Pro Tips for Eyebrow Maintenance
Maintaining your eyebrows doesn’t have to be a daunting task. With simple daily habits, you can keep your brows looking their absolute best. One effective method is eyebrow threading, which removes unwanted hairs and shapes your brows without the pain of waxing or time-consuming plucking. The process is quick, lasting around 5-6 weeks before another salon visit is needed.
For healthy and nourished brow hair, try massaging castor oil into your brows at night to strengthen and keep them looking full. If you only need minor shaping, use clean tweezers to pluck stray hairs, but be cautious not to overdo it, as this can lead to eyebrow thinning. Remember, a healthy diet is also key to maintaining your eyebrows. Focus on foods rich in omega-3s, vitamins, and antioxidants to promote overall hair growth, including eyebrow hair.
If you need to encourage regrowth after excessive tweezing, consider increasing iron intake.
Eyebrow Filler Application Advice
To achieve flawless eyebrow fillers every time, heed these essential tips.
Start with small increments: Gradually build coverage by adding filler in small doses. This allows for greater control over the final shape and color, resulting in a natural-looking finish.
Blend out clumps: After each application, use a clean spoolie to break up any clumps and blend the product seamlessly, ensuring the most natural appearance possible.
Embrace imperfections: Recognize that your eyebrows are unique and won’t be mirror images. Instead of striving for perfection, follow their natural shape and don’t overthink minor asymmetries.
Begin with simplicity: As a beginner, start with straightforward shapes and master the basics before attempting more complex designs. This will help you build confidence and develop your skills.
Less is often more: While bold brows may be trendy, excessive filler can lead to unnatural-looking results. Even if you desire a dramatic look, use restraint and blend carefully for a polished finish.
Alternatives to Eyebrow Fillers
While some individuals find eyebrow fillers to be an effective solution for maintaining their brow shape and color, others may prefer alternative options that offer a more permanent or long-lasting result. Two such alternatives are permanent tattoos and microblading. A permanent tattoo uses ink to fill in the brows, providing a lifetime solution with minimal maintenance required.
However, this option comes with a higher level of pain during the procedure, as well as the possibility of touch-ups if the ink fades over time. Microblading, on the other hand, is a semi-permanent procedure that mimics hair strokes to create a natural-looking brow. This method provides results that can last up to 18 months, making it a viable option for those seeking a longer-term solution than manual fillers.
While both alternatives do carry some risk of scarring or infection, they can be effective economical solutions for individuals who prioritize their brow appearance.
Fill Your Way to Stylish Eyebrows
When it comes to achieving the perfect eyebrow look, sometimes a little extra guidance is necessary. This is where high-quality eyebrow fillers come into play. With their help, you can not only fill in sparse areas but also shape and style your brows to fit your desired aesthetic. To get the most out of these products, be mindful of the color options available as well as the type of formula you prefer. By doing so, you’ll be well on your way to enjoying stylish, on-point eyebrows every day.
